Text Structure and Gradual Release of Responsibility

The structure of a text is a key tofamiliar plot structure of stories, tends to be
comprehension. Good readers "naturally" recognizerelatively easy for students to grasp, graphic
and respond to cues about the nature of a textorganizers such as story maps may help students
and adjust comprehension strategieskeep track of characters, settings, and other
accordingly—most of the time without eveninformation.
realizing they are doing so. This may work wellInitially, during the direct instruction and modeling
for them, but invisible acts are not useful forphases of lessons, teachers do most of the work.
struggling readers or for teachers who wish toAs students become more proficient, teachers
assist them. In fact, identifying and explicitlyprogressively expect students to identify and
applying comprehension strategies helps all readersanalyze text structures independently. This
because even skilled readers benefit fromapproach is known as the cheap d&g jewelry
understanding the met cognitive processes that"Gradual Release of Responsibility" framework
they are spontaneously using to comprehenddescribed by Harvey and Goudvis as a
texts.combination of modeling and guided practice that
Students may know that reading their biologyrequires a "delicate balance" between releasing
textbook is more difficult than reading Of Miceresponsibility too soon—resulting in
and Men, but they may not understand Likefrustration—and providing excessive
talented athletes, we probably became fluentinstruction—resulting in boredom and
readers and writers almost effortlessly, our skillsdisengagement. Harvey and Goudvis identify five
fostered by our passion for the Replica Cartierphases of the Gradual Release of Responsibility
Jewelry worlds we discovered and createdmodel: 1. Teacher modeling 2. Guided practice 3.
through language. Why; they are unlikely toCollaborative practice 4. Independent practice 5.
recognize features of the text structure thatApplication of the strategy in authentic reading
change their experiences of reading. In Strategiessituations
That Work; Teaching Comprehension forHarvey and Goudvis emphasize the point that
Understanding and Engagement, Stephanie Harveyteacher modeling should be brief and clear; the
and Anne Goudvis explain that Poetry has itspreponderance of instructional time should be
white space, fiction its characters, and nonfictiondevoted to students' practicing strategies as
its bold print. In fact, every literary genre or formteachers guide them through the process,
has certain features that define it. When weconstantly providing assistance, assessing
explore fiction, we teach our students aboutprogress, and modifying instruction. The crux of
character, setting, problem and solution. When wethe gradual release of responsibility model is that
investigate nonfiction, we share expository textmetacognition shifts from teacher-directed to
structures, such as "compare and contrast" andstudent-directed. Initially, teachers provide explicit
"cause and effect." We teach visual and textinstruction and supervise guided practice. Text
features so that students will have thestructure and comprehension strategies are
background knowledge to better comprehend aexplicitly taught, just like any other content, and
specific genre or form when they read and write.students are held accountable (through formative
In short, Harvey and Goudvis use research aboutand summative assessments) for their use of
what good readers do intuitively to recommendcomprehension strategies as much as they are
that teachers explicate text structures andfor their knowledge of content. After
provide strategies to help students engage withassessments indicate that students are capable of
different types of texts. Graphic organizers canapplying comprehension strategies independently,
be particularly valuable tools for facilitating textresponsibility for doing so shifts to them.
comprehension. Even though narrative text, the